Summit Home

Nancy Ortberg Responds to Session 5

Nancy Ortberg, our next guest blogger, is the best leader I have ever worked with (and I've worked with a lot of leaders). Serving on her staff team at Axis here at Willow Creek was a graduate-level class on leadership that forever changed me.

Nancy was a teaching pastor at Willow Creek for eight years. Under her leadership, Axis included weekend services of 1,200-1,500 people in their 20's who worshipped together, served the poor, and participated in small group communities.

She currently lives in the Bay Area in California and is a founding partner of Teamworx2, a consulting firm that works with organizations to help leaders overcome the team dysfunctions that are obstacles to high performance and work enjoyment.

While she is a remarkable pastor, speaker, and consultant, I’ve always thought she would also make an exceptional CEO or indispensable board member for a corporation that wanted to do good in the world and succeed wildly.

Here is Nancy’s response to Michael Porter’s session:

What Michael Porter talked about this morning has the potential to turn our churches from a soft, benign presence in our communities to an unstoppable force in our world. Forcing us to think one level up and deeper at the same time, he challenges our flurry of activities with the question, “How do we do well at doing good?”
 
He hits the nail on the head when he questions, “Is more better?” And churches would do well to consider the possibility that our desire to do good is not the same as doing good. His definition of doing good, which is focused on results, is clarifying at both the philosophical and practical levels.
 
Taking seriously his call to not “switch off our strategic thinking” because we are a church is helpful as we consider what, among the 1000’s of great causes, will we focus our great but limited resources of time, energy, and money. In doing this, I think we create the possibilities of releasing those resources in remarkable and “not-to-be ignored” ways.
 
And while his teaching and questions guided us well into an understanding of the right road to creating an effective and sustainable strategy, I think the larger win was this: How often, in our churches, do we honor those gifted with strategic minds and invite them to the discussion?

It is so easy to pick certain gifts as more spiritual than others. Administration trumps discernment, shepherding beats administration, and teaching trumps them all. You could insert any configuration to figure out what your particular church values, and we play rock, paper, scissors…

The strategic mind that he has is as much a gift from God as someone who prays diligently from their giftedness. Great leadership invites them all to the table.

 

Published 10 August 2007 01:27 PM by Ray Pelletier
Filed under: , , , ,

Email Post

Comments

# Rick DeVries said on 10 August, 2007 01:51 PM
Another reason to pay heed to Dr. Porter's insights is that by keeping an eye on strategic-directed effectiveness is that this is a stewardship issue as well. All of us, large and small congregation, NGO, not-for-profit or business ... scarce ministry resources (people's gifts, energy, time and money) are indeed just that - in limited supply.
Email Comment  |  Notify As Inappropriate
# Kevin Mahaffy said on 10 August, 2007 04:04 PM
Collins talked about maximizing your gifts/talents in areas of your strengths. He intimated that we should not volunteer in areas of our strengths. I see his point, but wonder how Christ would view it? He took on the roll of a servant - washed feet, cooked breakfast, etc. Would Collins say was a waste of Jesus' time and talents? How would others of you see this?
Email Comment  |  Notify As Inappropriate
# Rudy Neufeld said on 10 August, 2007 07:04 PM
Dr. Porter appropropriately challenges nonprofits and churches to clarify goals and seek observable, measurable results, as well as identifying how their actions will contribute toward furthering their core mission and vision. Certainly, we need to be accountable for money and time invested. However, Dr. Porter idoes not credit and perhaps is unaware of God's "hand" and activity at work in whatever Christ followers are doing. Furthermore, social transformation begins with many people or organizations independently and possbly inefficiently duplicate other's efforts. But there comes a "tipping point" or time when consciousness is raised and real changes result. God can take our 5 small loaves and 2 fishes and multiply them to meet the need. This is "hidden" from the wise but known to children.
Email Comment  |  Notify As Inappropriate
# Laura Bower said on 11 August, 2007 07:30 AM
Porter's model offers great insight into how we can begin to truly make a difference in some very pressing social situations. However, if there be an exception to his model, Jesus is certainly it. While at first glance it would appear that Jesus violated Porter's model of effectiveness by doing "menial" tasks such as washing feet and cooking breakfast, one could argue that everything that Jesus did or said was supremely effective, and thus completely worthy of His time. After all, some of his most talked about actions yet today are in fact these "menial" tasks. They had tremendous effectiveness and impact on our world today. Porter focuses on the motivating factor of effecting change and acheiving the highest social value. However, many acts are and should be motivated solely out of love. Regardless of the nature of the task, showing God's love to the world is always effective and will likely have a lasting impact far beyond earthly measure.
Email Comment  |  Notify As Inappropriate
# Connie Hecker said on 12 August, 2007 09:18 PM
"menial" tasks? Shouldn't that be an oxymoron? Isn't that what Jesus showed us? (oh, and what about the "ministers of first impressions?")
Email Comment  |  Notify As Inappropriate

Leave a Comment

(required) 
Email(required) 
(optional)




(required) 

Please enter the code above:
Thu | Fri | Sat
Bill Hybels
Carly Fiorina
Floyd H. Flake
Marcus Buckingham
Summit Schedule
 
The Leadership Store
 
The Leadership Store
 
Summit Programming
 
Summit FAQ
 
Register for 2008
 
Feedback on Website
 
Email your Summit photos here
 
 
   
WCA
Photos
Attenders'
Photos